Chullin 58

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today with the bottom line of the bottom. I'm going to write before this mentioned there is a regarding case of a that could be a how would you determine that it's a how would So one of the things that said is if it could give birth it's not a if If it can't give birth that means it's a if But there's another opinion about this that even if it could give birth it doesn't matter. Even a could give birth. So now in connection to this brings the following a a said honey be the a These eggs that come from a chicken that's a a Now the first batch of eggs that come from the chicken a they're going to be a And the reason for this is because if the chicken itself become becomes a so then whatever is inside the body when it became a becomes a together with the chicken. Because just like you say regarding an animal that when there's a fetus the the the fetus is considered to be like part of the body of the animal. Whatever the is regarding the body of the animal itself will apply to the fetus. The same also with the eggs. And actually so we'll see the will say but the eggs in a way it's even more so the eggs when they're inside the body of the chicken when they're still growing and developing there are that are connected to the body of the chicken that make them one with the body of the chicken and therefore if the mother is a a then the eggs will also be a a However

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today with the bottom line of the bottom. I'm going to write before this…
2. 3:41not not from the male and the female. The mother, the female itself, she got warmed…
3. 7:53mutar. That's the only way to explain this machlokes based on how we said the braisa…
4. 12:07is saying this way. That there is a chicken that became a treifa. And there's the…
5. 16:19Shimon sayver, but Rabbi Shimon's opinion is, "Ubar lav yerech imoi." That the fetus is considered…
6. 20:34be [clears throat] awesome. So that she explains the basis of what the is saying over…
7. 24:42didn't you have me be in this she's encouraging him to do not good things to…
8. 28:59the animal and he said that it's treif because of what he said it has an…
9. 33:11this, exactly where it has to join together. This is an argument between one opinion is…
10. 37:24that the small feathers are not what creates the protection. They're not needed for the protection…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.