Chullin 140

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Again today the gam very last word on the where it says so the here is explaining what it said in the Mishna that a non-coosher bird there's no mitzvah of what's the source brings because it says in the so it says not is a term that includes whether kosher or non-coosher bird in the refers only to for kosher bird. Now that was the source m here asked and will continue asking from a number of places where it seems like that the term is used even to non- kosher birds where it says on their branches live the birds of the sky. When it says it seems like birds of the sky includes kosher and non- kosher birds both of them live on the branch. So how can we say that means only a kosher bird when it says it's it's exact because even non- kosher birds are referred to as birds in the sky but we don't find in the that the word itself should be referring to a non-cos bird. It says in the that is what you could eat. That's the conclusion of the P. So now if it says that which is therefore you can eat it. So doesn't it mean that there's a bird that's a not not a bird and that's also called a there's a called and there's a called how could you say is only that's not how you have to interpret this rather what it's saying is it's talking only about the category of kosher birds but amongst the kosher birds when it says it means one that you can actually eat but then within the itself there's a bird That's to eat. What does this mean? What is the referring to here? when it says and amongst the there's one you can't eat if you would say it's referring to a

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Again today the gam very last word on the where it says so the here is…
2. 4:22why we have to have the beginning of the the first to teach about this if…
3. 8:44it's not if it's a it can't live besides this there's really another source for the…
4. 13:34be sent away and I say oh before I send it away let me go and…
5. 17:43correct you got you got rid of the bird. Okay, so this is the conclusion of…
6. 22:28sorry not the mother of the chicks that's a mitzvah of so the the way the…
7. 26:54then the sitting on top of the mitzvah does not apply to the only to the…
8. 31:16going to be and that is the point there is like we said before even if…
9. 36:00But I would think even if it's flying and hovering very closely to the nest itself…
10. 40:18that when the mother is on a branch on top of the nest you're so Then…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.