Chullin 134

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Again today the B the last line of the brings from what it said in the Mishna that if a is selling to aid then tells him I sell you this animal besides those sections of the animals that animal that's the gift for the cen that I'm accept this it's not in the sale. So then the owns now this animal doesn't have to give these gifts because those sections of the animal belongs to this ask contradiction on this from what it says if the cen selling the animal and he says I'm selling on the condition that these matonis remain mine. So then the bought the animal gets these matonis as part of the sale and it's his and he actually gives these matonis to whichever cayenne he wants. It doesn't remain by the seller of the cayenne and he keeps them. No, the buyer has to go now go and give these matonis to whoever he wants. So the answer is it's not the same thing as the mishna. You're asking from our Mishna that said that the K when he was selling used the term I'm selling you the animal except except this section that remains mine. He's not making a condition. He's just simply not selling that. And you're asking from there to the case over here in the where it says that he made a condition the term means that this I'm leaving out. It's not part of the sale. It's mine. So the keeps it for himself. Almanas the term almanas does not mean that he's

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Again today the B the last line of the brings from what it said in the…
2. 3:47the stomachs the part of the sections of the stomachs of the animal to someone. So…
3. 8:08that you could collect from either one of them. This is a statement there in Kame…
4. 12:22some kayen. Huh? But you have, but we're talking about the said before that when it's…
5. 16:44says mission is and in our mission we should have said the same thing that the…
6. 21:01so answered how could you compare the case of the case of our mission regarding the…
7. 25:22leave it in the field if there's no poor people to take this. So you can…
8. 29:42ownerless. Okay. So now nobody he doesn't own it anymore. So there's no den of giving…
9. 34:00matanis that go to the cayenne by the carbon ner that's the same section that goes…
10. 38:19So in the it says clearly that the shik is the right one. How do I…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.