Chullin 136

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today the first line where it says we're discussing here the opinion of law that said regarding that if it's an animal owned by partners there's no mitzvah of and he learns it from the fact that it says and the says or here is saying that even though we find similar that sounds like that it's a possession of an individual But nevertheless in all these cases he is partners are going to be might have brought the from um and now we continue to the next case where it also says but there's another term in the that clarifies even according to law the partners archive let's talk by it says the term the your grain singular term It sounds like only if it belongs to one person, not partners. But it says the plural term of even partners. So why does it say this term of in a singular term? It's only excluding a partnership with a guy but partnership with aid is going to be the next case when it comes to the gifts which is what we learned in the previous pic and the gifts that you give from an animal for the soman of even though the uses there the term of you should give. So you can say let's learn not the term here from the termina that it says just like according to law if it's partners so too with the gifts of the with a partnership you're not so the says there by the you take it from the one that slaughters and it uses the singular term but on

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today the first line where it says we're discussing here the opinion of law…
2. 3:18so this plural term this it says what is it coming to say something else as…
3. 7:06ending with the last case we said in Mah we say no over here there's something…
4. 10:59but you're not why wouldn't we say the same thing applies to that's in the same…
5. 14:38I should say the same thing regarding that I can't separate the combine animals from this…
6. 18:33you see that by you say that what grew from by the but what grew afterwards…
7. 22:24the very next thing the Mishna says is what happens if you have if a person…
8. 26:12that the are only with animals and it's this gam which is the source to explain…
9. 29:53there's no Oh say says learn not from another point actually learn not from to say…
10. 33:39is a different kind of mitzvah because that mitzvah you didn't heard already it says in…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.