Chullin 139

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today the three lines down from the top of the it said in the mitzvah of applies to birds that are but not a bird that's a carbon the mitzvah of does not apply so now asks this what is the case that we're talking about that there's a bird that is a carbon and on this we need to say that the mitzvah of would not apply So is the case that a person has a nest of birds in his house and so it's his he owns it and it's in his possession. So he's able to make it hectish or carbon and he did so. But the thing is that's where you need the Mishna to say that there's no iss that would apply here says if you will encounter a nest of a bird and what does that mean? Something that is prepared and it's in your possession the mitzvah does not apply. So over here it can't be speaking aboutish that's in your possession that you were makish. So must be what's the case here? The camema a person sees a nest of a bird. It's just anywhere that's outside in the on the road in the street and he went ahead and he was and on this is saying that the mitzvah of would not apply. But the question is if a person is something that is in the out in the field and it doesn't own it, it's not in his possession, would this

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today the three lines down from the top of the it said in the…
2. 3:44is something that he have found out in the field. So once it was from before…
3. 7:59so explains the difference between their opinions it's understood by they're saying very similar but did…
4. 11:50away it still maintains its ofish and its ownership of ask but once it runs away…
5. 16:04is when he says the term of that he took the responsibility on himself goes together…
6. 20:00and the of the third category of [clears throat] when a person says that my value…
7. 24:08kind of when a person says I give to even if he did not specify and…
8. 27:55the word just like the is that it's not in your possession. So to the mitzvah…
9. 32:09Says the earth that's on his head. So you see that even after you place earth…
10. 35:53Hordes already died but the ones that came from Hordis they heard this and they took…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.