Chullin 13

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Again today the gamut B one two eight eight lines up from the bottom of the where it says the here in the beginning of the mentioned about the here before explained that should not be even if and as someone that was observing the entire then it'll be explained before because when you it's not necessary to have any if the was done okay then it's going to be accepted. Okay. So in connection to this the he brings from ask the following a does he have a meaning that could we use the fact when he does an action that what's required is not just an action but he also has to have a kavana does have that ability to have a kavana of lishma. So for example when it comes to you have to are we relying on the cotton that he has that ability to have that says when he heard this question why is asking this sh regarding the of a cotton he should have a shil regarding the action of a cotton. Now what does the gum mean when it says this word of misa? It sounds like the gumar is asking we should be asking whether a cotton's action is valid or not. But that's not the shila. If a cotton does an action, the physical action, you see the action is done. Obviously the action is valid. The shila when it says here in the gum the word as we'll see from the continuation of the gum and explains here that what it's saying is he should have had a sha in a case where you need makov. The word mice also refers to the but in a case where the action of the cotton clearly shows you that he understands what the purpose is what he's doing. So he should have a shil regarding a case where the mis is a

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Again today the gamut B one two eight eight lines up from the bottom of the…
2. 3:50because the Mishna says if a child takes an acorn pomegranate so the child is playing…
3. 7:37it means that he's doing something which is not conclusive but you could assume that this…
4. 11:52Kon brings this fruits up to the rooftop. Even if they're having an intention for this…
5. 15:31his was regarding the action of the child when a when a child does an action…
6. 19:43whole different mahalaka to learn this >> way in any of these do you have to…
7. 23:21carry then not only if you touch it but even if you're not touching it even…
8. 27:16pours it's all if it's a safer that he wrote even if he wrote But now…
9. 31:35right this is the statement is you look at the words here it's not clear it…
10. 35:14away if he's serving away you can't accept from him the carbon that's but when the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.