Menachos 93

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We're getting ready to go on outside the Gimel, three lines down from the top of the Amud. The Gimel goes back to what it said in the Mishna Saimach. A person that an animal carbon from his father, he brings the carbon in the place of his father. And the mitzvah of Smeicha also applies to the Yiddish to the inheritor. So the Gimel told Kamay of Chananya told a Brysa in front of Rava that said Yiddish ain't no Saimach. That an inheritor does not have the mitzvah of Smeicha on the animal he's bringing from his father. And also Yiddish ain't no Maymer. A Yiddish cannot do Temurah. Which means that if a person has a carbon and he says I'm exchanging this for another animal. What happens is the now the Kedusha takes effect on the other animal and they both are now a carbon. But that a Yiddish can't do. The original, the father that he was Makdish this animal, could affect the Temurah, but not the Yiddish. Now in our Mishna it also said Maymer, that a Yiddish could do Temurah. The Gimel asks for an answer now. And in our Mishna it said both a Yiddish Saimach. A Yiddish has a mitzvah of Smeicha. Who may be in the Sachav. And he also brings the Sachav for the carbon. Who Maymer. And he could do Temurah. So we have a contradiction from what it what he taught here in the Brysa to from the Mishna. Amalay so of Chananya says to Rava if so if Choy. Should I just change the words of the Brysa and instead of reading it that ain't no Saimach, take out the word the ain't and it should be like what it said in the Mishna that a Yiddish could be Saimach and he could do Temurah.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We're getting ready to go on outside the Gimel, three lines down from the top of…
2. 2:34the word carbonite we learn that it's only on his carbon. If the father itself he's…
3. 5:50So, he doesn't hold of that drasha. So, he has one carbona here that's extra to…
4. 8:56or a shliach, you're doing uh a smicha for someone else. V'ha'isha. And a woman as…
5. 11:34you're blind. And Rashi brings the sources that can't have a mum. Different sources with this…
6. 14:49command of Parah. That's where we learn it out the command of that when it says…
7. 17:56>> Speaking about her own korban? >> when a woman brings her own korban, she doesn't…
8. 20:31sounds like it's saying that if you do then it will be accepted the question is…
9. 23:45it's not excluded from the midst of smicha. It's necessary to say that it is excluded.…
10. 26:54if it's his own or maybe it was but he didn't say it in the Rish…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.