Bava Metzia 18

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin today the seven lines up from the bottom of the the before brought a statement that said there's a concept called and that's a condition that bz obligates you to pay and it refers to even if you don't write a you still have to pay the because there's a very strong obligation to pay and you won't be believed to say that you paid up unless you have proof for this from if you just claim that you paay up you won't be believed that was that he said so on this brought a where it says pretty clearly this thing a woman brings a g just to proof that she was divorced and she has no she can collect so you see right over there in that Mish this point then AB discusses this AB says but maybe that mishna is talking about a situation where people don't write a subba then AB comes back and says no no no because by Adis you don't write a and nevertheless she has power to collect her without writing a why how why can't anybody claim the children or the husband themselves if he divorces or after Adison say that it was paid up it must be that there's this power ofin because is azdin so therefore you can you can collect it and uh the husband can't claim that he paid it up unless he has a cleared eye for this that's what thear concluded until here so the here is going to question the whole premise of this whole point here that even by Adison there's an obligation to pay even

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin today the seven lines up from the bottom of the the before brought a statement…
2. 3:11writes into the says all those additional things that the husband is gifting her his wife…
3. 6:21written it's a from Adis that get so the asks again how do you know maybe…
4. 9:40Remains with what power is she collecting even in a place where there's a minut not…
5. 12:56off don't return it to the person belongs to why because I say maybe all these…
6. 16:04point is the whole concern that we're saying when there's a lot of people traveling here…
7. 19:21people come and go there it's a be that's busy and the and what's rabing here…
8. 22:30you see here in this clearly says if the husband agrees that you should give the…
9. 25:40doesn't say that clearly in a mishna it's just a DI that we made so maybe…
10. 28:45place that there's a lot of people traveling there by a get you won't be able…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.