Kidushin 51

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin today the towards the bottom of the two lines from the bottom where it says so the before over here brought what RAB said that that when we have something that according to it cannot work to to one after the other the example that was brought for this is to marry a woman and then a sister a so the then a sister a so the it's a and you can't K won't take effect so if you try to be mades two sisters at once none of them will be mes and that's the explanation for what it says in the Mna together they're not mes so here the gar will bring the statement of RAB and discuss it bring from other sources where we find seemingly that it does work so said this rule rule anything that you cannot have it take effect one after the other even if you try to do it together that it should take effect at once it will not take effect asked on this a person that is separating his M and he gave extra M now m is a set amount you give a tenth from the produce but if a person gave double he gave a fifth so what happened so the produce is meer he took offer now but since he took off extra but the actual that he separated so that with that it's m is a problem with this what's the problem so Rashi explains you have Myer and that are mixed with one another since you only have to give a tenth Meer and this person gave double he gave a fifth Myer so only half of it is really Myer the other half is so now in this Myers you

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin today the towards the bottom of the two lines from the bottom where it says…
2. 4:04over here what happened is when this person is separating and he's saying that a fif…
3. 8:11have but over here we learned this from suim that if a person made this kind…
4. 12:2680 but if the person specified and said I don't want just a 40 alone to…
5. 16:38there so here the is going to bring about this subject and a long discussion about…
6. 21:20women and two out of them the K cannot take effect because the sisters so if…
7. 25:25meant is the person came madesh he says I'm being mades one out of you one…
8. 29:37was it says a plural term that the are not included and from that we understand…
9. 33:40know what did I have in mind who was I thinking about when I accepted it…
10. 37:50to do that later there should be no spus about it so he definitely meant the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.