Sukkah 23

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we begin today at the mishnah on the bottom of the bay summit bays one builds a sukkah on the top of a wagon on the top of a ship shaira it's kosher says rashi explains the hidden of the fact that it's kosher when it's on top of the wagon even though the wagon is movable and it's not adidas like the opinion of yehuda nevertheless this tan assassin it's kasha this tan assassin it's kasha and the kid is regarding is that it's in a very open area where there's a strong wind and the sukkah could fly away easily so it's not it may not even be adida at all it can't live there at all nevertheless the mishnah says it's kasha and the gemara will explain exactly what case we're talking about the oil-in-law be yamtif these are sukkas that are kosher and could be used on yantif as well now she says there really is no kurdish about the fact that it could be used in yomtif there should be no reason why not but because in the next case at a mission it will bring a case where it mission it will bring a case where it can't be used for young tiff so it says here that it could but shaylan you made this sick on top of a tree oil gabagon molar on a camel shadow this okay is kosher however you can't go on to it on yantif this is one of the zeidas of ghazal regarding chavez and yamtif you're not allowed to go on a tree and you're not going to go on an animal on yantif you might come to pull off something from the tree and you might come to a pull up something for the animal so therefore you're not allowed to go on them on shabbos and yantif

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we begin today at the mishnah on the bottom of the bay summit bays one builds…
2. 2:02made over there in the tree itself and then they have one wall that's positioned on…
3. 4:12there was once when millionaire kiva were traveling on a boat on sukkis got up and…
4. 6:46that there is on the underwater me so it's not a good sucker it has to…
5. 8:49but the ship a sucker that can't be used for seven days which is this sukkah…
6. 11:24how about if you use the body of an animal as a wall for your sukkah…
7. 13:26for the wall of a my time that may ye what's the reason for that mei's…
8. 15:30animal may die we should also be concerned that it will run away isn't that a…
9. 18:02the one that says that what we're concerned about over here is that it may die…
10. 20:11and her husband went overseas and we're not sure what happened to him is he alive…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.