Bava Basra 137

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

nine lines up from the bottom of the where it says so the gar is discussing the concept of K pis when a person only has ownership on a property only the fruits of it only the usage of it not the body of the property itself the case was it began with the mishna where it says a father that gives away to his children the property and he keeps for himself the payis and he's giving away the body of the propery to his children and then when he passes away his children will when he passes away his children will get it fully that's the case where that the mishna speaks about and then based on that are discussing this if the the son went ahead when the father was still alive and sold sold the property to someone else and the son died before the father died does that buyer get anything so says that no the buyer gets nothing why because the father that owns the pis of this property that ownership is a very strong ownership it's like he owns the body itself because he's the only the body itself because he's the only one that can use it it's like he owns the the whole property so therefore the son has no ability to sell it in the father's lifetime that a buyer would get it even if the son is not alive at all when the father died but says that no the fact that the father owns the pis does not prevent the son of selling it to anyone else even if the son dies before the father because the F the the father only owns pis he owns the usage of it but the body of the property itself already belongs to the son so you can sell it that was a before so here

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03nine lines up from the bottom of the where it says so the gar is discussing…
2. 3:35either it's going to stay by the inheritors of the of the first recipient that's the…
3. 7:41the it doesn't stay by the first recipient so this is actually a question now on…
4. 11:51first recipient that is whether he can sell it to someone else or not or the…
5. 16:00however he says will agree again so what did say that the first recipient could sell…
6. 20:08regarding how The Works maybe he retracted from what he said before that would agree that…
7. 23:47shrouds You could also do that and now the the second recipient will have nothing from…
8. 27:57the that that it's yours that you for sure could be and here adds by the…
9. 32:07yours or by TR over there the is it could be partners and you still to…
10. 36:13away it's sold so here is giving it away to his own son and his son…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.