Sukkah 40

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we begin today in the gemara and madalif where it says time with the lulu the first word of the line is bain the gemada here is discussing the said in the mishnah regarding shmita that if you're buying the dialed minim from an amma that's in the year shmita so then you should get the asterisk from him as a gift don't pay for it the kamado explained before that if you pay in amma audits for the esrig that money has the kedusha of shmita and we're concerned that our models will we're concerned that our models will misuse that money but by lulav we don't have that concern so the gemara questioned that what's the difference between lulav and aesthetic seemingly they both have the kedush of shemitah and iguana answer the difference is that regarding a lulav the status of the shmitah is defined by when it began to grow so in the beginning of the year shmitah that lulav which began to grow in the sixth year is not part of shmitah whereas the esrig we define whether it's part of schmitt or not according to when it was picked from the tree and therefore the esrig was picked tree and therefore the esrig was picked in this year of schmidt and therefore does it is parshmita that's a distinction but the point is that the gemara is saying that the status of of shmitah applies to a lulav and to an estric the only difference in our case is regarding the lulav and aesthetic whether we go balikita or basakhanata as the language of the gemara before was so the mother now is going to question this whole premise here is it really true that the halakhas of shmita the kedusha of schmitter applies even to a lulav

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we begin today in the gemara and madalif where it says time with the lulu the…
2. 3:04oven to burn in the oven to have a fire so then aim bamboo shrimp the…
3. 6:46oven only after it turns into charcoal so the hana comes after the beer so the…
4. 10:18answer of ravi the gemara is retracting what it said before that the only distinction between…
5. 13:53the way you consume the produce of shmitah that has kedusa is to eating for eating…
6. 17:31for all your needs that includes even for washing as well so hamani mikhail so therefore…
7. 21:07usually the term is khalelis means that you're transferring that there was the kedusha on one…
8. 24:40money becomes now hectic she's rashi here brings the sukim the behectish either way the money…
9. 28:39have the kadush of schmidt anymore that's not the case thomas yeah therefore the pasik by…
10. 32:13whether they're alive benjamin whether they were already slaughtered doesn't make a difference you can bring…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.