Bava Basra 150

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We're going to learn the Gemara on daf kuf nun amud alef, nine lines down from the top of the amud where it says "v'chol heiche". The Gemara is discussing what it said in the Mishna when a sh'chiv mera, a dying person says he's giving a gift, so if he left over a little bit for himself in this gift, so then even if he recovers, that so usually we say a person that's gave everything away and now he recovers, we understand that he didn't mean to give it all away, so he can take it back. But if when he gave it away, the Mishna said he left a kol sh'hu for himself, a little bit he left for himself, a little bit he left for himself, so then even if he recovers, he can't retract from this gift. Now the Gemara before brought what Rav said that kol sh'hu in the Mishna doesn't mean literally a kol sh'hu, kol sh'hu means k'dei parnasa'sei. It's to be an amount that would be enough to be able to support himself. Then he, since he kept that amount for himself, so he can't retract from the gift. And the Gemara, Abaye asked on this or Rav Yosef asked on this, the Mishna says kol sh'hu, which means a tiny drop. How could you say that the word kol sh'hu in the Mishna means k'dei parnasa'sei, which is much more than a tiny drop?

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We're going to learn the Gemara on daf kuf nun amud alef, nine lines down from…
2. 3:06called Shane? Oh my God, so that explained it means Mona or brass. The total amount…
3. 6:09that a person says the plan here. Movable items that I have should be given as…
4. 9:11sold." Okay, so now, the Gemara starts first with what it said in the reisha of…
5. 12:43d'avina rashi to shama. Ha kaseiv, a person that writes, we had this before in the…
6. 15:47and he gives something to his wife. So as long as he gives something to his…
7. 18:51connection to the husband. So if in that very document itself it says other information that…
8. 22:24but he's keeping 10% for the children, then in such a case it is going to…
9. 25:26take back from this person that she gave it as a gift to. Now, another thing…
10. 28:28now he goes free and he gets all of his master's possessions so we see that…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.