Bava Basra 171

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

one that paid up part of his loan so let's say the loan was $1,000 and he paid up $500 now he what's going to be here the lender has a document that says that he owes $1,000 what do you do with that document can he just put down there minus five let's see let's see says so you switch the document that original document you tear up you're gonna write minus five so he'll tear off that minus five we already had before in the gamar that we're always concerned that he could uh play around or erase so you tear up the original document and you switch it with a new one says that what happens is the lender gives the borrower a receipt that he paid 500 and in the future if he wants to collect so he'll have the receipt that 500 was paid but says no it's not right to do this because n comes out that that the borrower always has to protect this receit from mice or from whatever that he should always have that proof so why put that burden on him that he should always have to protect it says this is the right thing this is the right thing for the lender because the lender did him a favor and lent him money so so the lender is the one that should have the upper hand over here and therefore it's the right thing that he could say I'm just giving you a receipt and we're not going to take away the power of the lender that he can keep his original document and what this means is based on what here says say

Jump to a moment

1. 0:08one that paid up part of his loan so let's say the loan was $1,000 and…
2. 3:18new you're gonna have to go to bz and they're going to tear up the original…
3. 6:26the Bez that's Ra's opinion here okay so as I explained the the basis of this…
4. 9:35so what the first one the first star was there the second star there but now…
5. 12:52you put the date from today then po the reason why I argue on you is…
6. 16:06of and you said that it is says when I said it's it's only in this…
7. 19:17later date that shows that he lent the money again so it could be a big…
8. 22:31so holy that will put it into our eyes so in other words he's saying true…
9. 25:40that were even from that original date which really are not there's no lean on them…
10. 29:02follows when you write a that's going to be post you should WR make it clear…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.