Rosh Hashanah 26

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we begin at the bottom of daffodil with bayes la membrana de aidnacidaine so this is going over here on the discussion in the gemada when you had uh the last case the kimono brought here is when you have three of besdon to make up for basdin and they all saw the moon together so what did it say what do you do you take two of them to be the witnesses and then one could be a judge and that one has to combine another two so there should be three together and that side that could be mikadash the new month so the gemara now says we can prove something based on this remember shall we say that what do we see from here the aid nasa dying that an aide someone that's when the mother says aid now as rashi explains it means someone that's fit to be a witness someone that witnessed what happened see even though he himself saw what happened nevertheless later he can become a dying he can be a judge in this case all three saw the moon and they're all three fit to be witnesses nevertheless one of them is going to become a dying right so okay now the gemara doesn't explain what would be the issue with this why should someone that witnessed something not be allowed to become then a judge again the german is not talking about someone that's actually a witness and that the witness should also be the judge that wouldn't make any sense that someone that actually is testifying should be a judge that's not what we're talking about but the king what is saying someone that saw what happened and and is potentially a witness could be a judge instead of being a witness why not so the israelites speak about this

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we begin at the bottom of daffodil with bayes la membrana de aidnacidaine so this is…
2. 3:09talking about an issue of life of a person that's already said and you want to…
3. 6:15the carnatic aim karnov that this is the old oldest shirt and it has nice horns…
4. 9:24the reason for that not enter with the gold garments into the kurdish aqueduction to serve…
5. 12:38nevertheless because it's lizzy cotton there's an issue of category tyson says that when you blow…
6. 15:41how does it grow it it grows and it becomes like one piece it's not like…
7. 18:49this in the pastic it says you faint knife a beautiful appearance messiah's color or it's…
8. 21:55one at a time they were coming yet one at a time so um she commented…
9. 25:12of rabbi you this is we're talking here about the schaefer that's used specifically in the…
10. 28:18is a straight shafer so why is he saying that we take the curved tree from…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.