Bava Kama 44

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we begin today the 1520 lines up from the bottom of the at the end of the line where it says the continues to discuss of the payment of when a GES and kills a person so he said in the name of the when it says it could have said in the you pay why does it say if you would place the payment of the word IM is extra what it's calling to add is that you pay whether the G and killed someone or whether it GED and killed someone what's the difference when when the kill someone the sh itself has to be put to death the is so then if you if the sh is you pay even if the sh itself did and the sh does not have to be put to death you still pay this is this is what says but we had before in the disagrees holds you only pay if the is put to death so this this Isn from that no is not dependent on whether the is put to death based on this if so shouldn't we say the same by an by the if you and kill a you pay or so what does it say by the over there it also uses the extra word of if will be G so there you should as well that iford whether either way you should pay the of the say and say yeah true the word there as well the same way says that Gordon killed unintentionally you don't pay those so why don't you dasing the word [Music] there

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we begin today the 1520 lines up from the bottom of the at the end of…
2. 3:47writes what's the difference what's the difference because the extra word of that it says by…
3. 8:06write to say that coton like a GLE so the says you can't say this because…
4. 12:14refers to a cotton if they are Mas someone they're Potter right as rash brings we…
5. 15:59the time as well it's also learned from the we can't learn from says the says…
6. 20:11says the case is that the sh is a m that it fell into already three…
7. 24:25all four cases and here we see clear not like how do you have this if…
8. 28:20but I don't want to learn out from the payment of why not the payment of…
9. 32:37person that threw a rock into a crowd of people he what is this case over…
10. 36:55no it says in the in this where it talks about the that it says seven…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.