Menachos 49

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin today the Gmorra ones right at the beginning the continues relating to the lambs that are brought together taught in front of the following the lambs of so for the purpose of it being rams None of us are a different carbon. So he taught that the carbon will be but >> the owners which refers to all Eden this is a carbon that's being brought for everyone the obligation with this carbon has not been fulfilled. So rav commented and told him no that it cautioned it took effect and they fulfilled their obligation even if it was done. Okay. So now when this brings what did mean to say when he said that even though it was done the carbon will still be and not only kosher but also they fulfilled the obligation. usually by the carbon itself is but the owners in this case the does not fulfill the obligation says it's logical to say like said that he has rams in front of him but he's thinking he's doing it so he's shacking for the purpose of it being lambs. Right? So really they were lambs. He's thinking that they're alim but he's thinking in other words he he thinks he has in front of him and he's though for the sake of lambs. So in such a case it's says it'll be why because in fact they are lambs and heed it for the purpose of lambs. He just made a mistake thinking that they're rams in front of him. Okay. So then

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01begin today the Gmorra ones right at the beginning the continues relating to the lambs that…
2. 2:44with it. So even though the mistake over here wasn't just a thought, the mistake was…
3. 6:00question is what is a case of pigle what are we talking about over here is…
4. 9:15shallow pan and you did it you clearly see that it's not what it is. So…
5. 11:57right in front of us that it is a mistake over here this which is a…
6. 15:05you still bring the in the afternoon they're not connected that if you didn't bring one…
7. 18:15you can either the shil is when you have the carbonus and now you're not if…
8. 20:55this Mishna saying either one since over here you have the the Um so I'm erased…
9. 24:15And that's not really he has enough for the foren of here. What it's saying is…
10. 27:26inspected lambs but you should have also a seventh available for Tuesday morning. Now this is…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.