Menachos 56

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

again the ones five lines up from the bottom of the where it says so the here before brought up where the says by the carbon of the soy a goat that ai a king brings so it says what does that teach that it's on the toughen on the north of the just like an now the question the is discussing here is Why does it say the term? Because this is not only by the it's by every as the brings for that. So the word that it says here in this has to be excluding something. What exactly is it coming to exclude? That will be the discussion here and the continuation of the gum. So now that we learn out from another that says that all have to be done and so when it says the term regarding the carbon of the what is it coming to exclude says the gum the first suggestion you know we have a simmon for the different things the gum will suggest. So the first thing the says is the goat that and so to all the nian brought when the nianim brought their carbon by the starting from so their carbon which was also a does not have to be done in sen that's what it's coming to exclude now why would I think that it should be done in senite Because I would think to say since I find the willable bringer that the does apply by the carbon of the soften. So maybe this of that has to be done and soften should apply to the carbon of the as well. Therefore the says by the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00again the ones five lines up from the bottom of the where it says so the…
2. 2:41says this comes to say that by the you need as well says that that there…
3. 6:00there's no reason to compare that's for that time period to a regular in all generations.…
4. 9:06because if when it comes to an animal where the of the animal does not have…
5. 12:30this point already taught from a different explains that he learned from the word that it…
6. 15:38discussed this but even if the shaping happens when it's in the oven but the one…
7. 18:51opinions about this. So the first is that this has this blood clot. You're allowed to…
8. 22:04the opinions over here. Okay. So the point that the is going to focus on is…
9. 25:14these whether you can make a m an animal that already has a okay so says…
10. 28:22going back to the of the not allowed to make says if you placed sourdough on…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.