Nedarim 8

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

again today the gamada at the very last words and of Zion with Bass the Omar of giddle umarav statement from before the gamada brought a statement from bringing here another statement from which is related to the subject that we're talking about in armor sector right at the beginning of Darkness from where do I know that a person can take an oath to fulfill a mitzvah and what was the oath foreign was understanding that what RAV was saying is that when you make this saying is that when you make this actually has the power and it takes effect and now when you fulfill it you have to hold the Mitzvah not only because it's a Mitzvah but if you're not gonna fulfill the Mitzvah then you're being either on your and you'll you'll get separately Marcus for being over on that but the gamada asks that the should not take effect at all and the reason is the Iran here brings from what it says that in the title when it speaks about the idea of a schwa it uses the term that you make ashua for something negative to abstain let's say from negative to abstain let's say from eating or you make a sure and the positive that I will eat but the termitive shows that a Shu only takes effect regarding any permissible thing regarding a Mitzvah which you can't say if it's not your choice whether to do it or not to do it for that the shua doesn't take effect in the first place there's no for a Mitzvah so how can we say that a person is totally ineffective Allah answers this is what Rob was telling me not that it actually takes

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01again today the gamada at the very last words and of Zion with Bass the Omar…
2. 2:40accustomed to making sure because then you might not even fulfill yours for us so you…
3. 5:18this is the same point that afghill said before in the name of regarding every mids…
4. 7:51because I don't know why it spells it out only the second time he's doing even…
5. 10:27they can't be part of this minion to uh to uh this Nido and we like…
6. 13:05to remove it says she said not necessarily this person came to you in a dream…
7. 15:40ASI he came and asked ravashi about his wife's net there the fact that his wife…
8. 18:17be so annoyed by his wife's nether he's living with her so he might be so…
9. 20:51this is really two separate Allah which is connected to what we learned before it's not…
10. 23:37says a different shot on the Posse he said this does not refer to ganaden after…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.