Bava Basra 169

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

six lines up from the bottom of the we learn a person comes along and says I lost a document of my loan A lender he says I lend someone money but I lost the document I can't collect my law I can't prove the that he owes me this money so even yes it's true this person lent someone money we wrote thear for him we signed money we wrote thear for him we signed it we gave it to him he's not making up a story we're not going to write him a second document of a loan to collect his loan why because we're concerned maybe he didn't lose this document maybe he just hit it somewhere and now he's going to have two documents and collect twice or maybe he's not maybe he is honest maybe he did lose it but maybe he's going to find it later and then once he's going to find it he's going to be tempted to uh collect twice so therefore we can't write him a second document the Mas however here does say that if it's a Mas however here does say that if it's a case where you have a him that he lost it somewhere in the street where it's not expected that he'll find it again such a case we will write him a second document but if he lost it somewhere in his house and it's possible he would find it again so then we're afraid to write him a secondar when is this the case regarding a person that says that he lost a document of a loan if a person a buyer that has the document of the sale the deed and now he comes and tells us he says he lost the document to prove

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03six lines up from the bottom of the we learn a person comes along and says…
2. 3:36The Giver gave you that it's now yours you give it back to the one that…
3. 7:10second buyer and the second buyer takes that star and shows the seller look I have…
4. 11:16this buyer we tear Hisar now we teared thear of the loan so how could he…
5. 14:53loan we only need this when is there a concern there what happened is the first…
6. 19:01well when a person gets paid up a loan do you write a receipt or do…
7. 22:34concerned that they don't have the receipt but won't they go back to the seller and…
8. 26:08the first person that he confiscated from how is that going to help you for him…
9. 30:13you write you write this new document but besides the right to be able to get…
10. 33:47said you now have to go and you're going to be the buyer from this seller…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.