Bava Metzia 36

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin where it says the first word on the line is a little bit after the mishna so this here is based on what it said in the mishna regarding a case of a and a what's the difference between the responsibility of the when the R so then he's responsible for and maybe even for the but he's definitely not responsible for any that happens that then that goes and lends it to someone else that sh now and lends it to someone else that sh now is responsible for even if it's MES so what happens now if you lend it out to someone else that is lends it out to someone else and in the possession of the sh this animal dies anus so the as far as his contract with this renter is concerned he doesn't have to pay him for this it's anus but as far as the the responsibility the contract between the which now lended to someone else he has responsibility to pay back the mash the responsibility to pay back the mash the which is also a mash he lent it out to someone else for the fact that it died so according to the T the mishna it comes out that the original owner loses because an happened he doesn't get paid for that but the which now lent it out to someone else and the deal the contract the responsibility between him and the one that lent it from him was that you're going to be responsible even for anus he's going to have to pay the for this sinus so the sort of gains off the back of the owner which loses out here and he's he's is going to gain the payment that was said the argued says no

Jump to a moment

1. 0:02begin where it says the first word on the line is a little bit after the…
2. 3:38that okay so now just if you stop over here so this this is where the…
3. 7:43borrowed it the second time for 70 days and now this animal dies when the animal…
4. 11:52times goes back to the owner huh day go back according to so the automatic default…
5. 15:27responsibility of the is only for and the responsibility of the is even for so says…
6. 19:35responsible for the for the and would also be for this so therefore they're trying to…
7. 23:42put on the that happened after he gave it over to another Sher he remains in…
8. 27:16you're going to be responsible for this said about this argument or really about the opinion…
9. 31:26naturally anus so then the just swears that that it was anus that happened and therefore…
10. 35:32anytime a person gives someone something to guard for him he's giving it with the understanding…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.