Sanhedrin 33

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin to one line down from the top of the going back to what it said in the m d the Miss says when it comes to money matters if a mistake was made in the verdict whether it was innocence or guilt either way byus the is turned back because of the mistake says I'll ask a contradiction from what it says in the following mishna mishna a judge in a case where he someone that was supposed to be guilty he made him innocent or the opposite is someone that was supposed to be innocent he made him guilty or something that was supposed to be pure he said that it's impure but the opposite here is so in all these cases the the verdict is done you don't turn it back and then this judge is going to have to pay then this judge is going to have to pay for whatever loss was caused by his so we clearly see here that once it's a it's an effect you don't change it we go back on okay so the is going to bring a number of answers three or four answers on this contradiction says it's not a contradiction in the case of our Mish we're talking about an expert judge and the we're talking about here says is a

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01begin to one line down from the top of the going back to what it said…
2. 4:11in such a case we go back on the verdict and where it says you don't…
3. 8:15you have the ability to argue on them that's the get to itself but from this…
4. 12:23himself he said well I'm gonna have to not reimburse for the loss that I caused…
5. 17:08saying if you're going to say that when a person made a mistake even regarding but…
6. 21:10cause the damage it's a g it's pretty direct but you didn't do it so therefore…
7. 25:13was guilty so so that way you can understand the case is the originally the said…
8. 29:57that's what it has to mean just like we said when when it says the terms…
9. 34:07made it so it's not just words it means an action the a the bz wanted…
10. 38:16it says there so it's the same thing you don't go back what's someone that there…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.