Bava Kama 108

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin the three lines from the bottom of the asked the following question as rash explains this refers to something that we learned a few times earlier in the that there's a case where a person pays C and there's a case where you you pay AAS the of paying with an usually the difference is that if you falsely regarding aot that you had and then a them come and say that it was that you you the one that stole it then you pay but in a case where the person admitted himself so then you p and but we had before it said in a case where a came and therefore you're paying even if he's going to admit it afterwards you don't pay once you pay you don't pay as well so a what's the what exactly is the in this that if you pay you don't P huh yeah once you pay there's no so this is it because regarding this money this P that you're already paying for so you don't pay again for it or maybe that's not the point it's the fact that you a and it's the that's obligating you to pay and therefore that same sh will not obligate you to pay and the explains in what case there would be a between these two approaches what what Cas is in a of first came and claimed that it got stolen from him and V and then and he swore that it got stolen from him and then later then he came and he claimed not that it got stolen but it got lost and

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin the three lines from the bottom of the asked the following question as rash explains…
2. 4:16got stolen and aen came for that for that he pays C and maybe for the…
3. 8:58pays over here yeah yeah if he was Ma and there was no ad he's pay…
4. 13:20two different but even then it if it turns out that the second B made him…
5. 18:01away since he swore first to ped himself and then he paid up so therefore the…
6. 22:47owner gets the C so here you see the exact opposite the reason why the Sher…
7. 27:12we look at the fact that when it came to the owner himself he he was…
8. 32:05oh so now says since we're saying that the whole what it depends upon over here…
9. 36:21you but you decided to pay to pay we're also trying to help you out I'm…
10. 41:09Rashi says over here that is Mitzvah it's his Mitzvah to to go after this to…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.