Chullin 39

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin today the three lines down from the top of the y the gim here is going to discuss the of a person that'sing a carbon that belongs to a goaling a carbon not carbon again we're talking about here an animal and in the Mishna it spoke about an animal that belongs to a guy and the guy has in mind that this should be for the sake of a [snorts] so now in connection to this the brings a when an animal for the sake of a let's see we learned the following someone's shing an animal but the itself he had no intention that the should be for the sake of but when he's shing what he's thinking is that he's going to spray its blood for he's going to take the fats of the animal and he'll burn it for the sake says although at the time of the it wasn't being done for the sake of but since he was thinking that then the or the will be for that pass the itself now the word over here some are actually greatest in the it means that the will become because just like if you the animal for the sake of so that that everybody agrees it makes here later in the brings the source for this that something that you is called and a mess is so too when you sh something for the sake of it's so says even though the was not done but you had in mind that or the will be it

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin today the three lines down from the top of the y the gim here is…
2. 3:56this regarding. So they followed their opinions. They also argued regarding another case because we learned…
3. 7:57okay so now the brings from our Mishna on to ask a question actually on both…
4. 11:47that later should be it's not going to it most definitely We should also be lenient…
5. 15:36does pass? So the says law that the one that asked the question of he gave…
6. 19:29that's the owner of the animal he wants it to be so and the say that…
7. 23:14brought up that there's a concept called that what you see in the end proves what…
8. 26:59that happened later and the is not good enough to to write it to give a…
9. 30:46retracting and he says I don't want efi. Efi is not a language that you could…
10. 34:31the blood and the fats of this animal that ising that's what we want the hide…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.