Makos 19

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today the B the last line we're in the talk bringing the to the from what point would that is not supposed to eat from the from what point would he be if he eats from these Rashi. So the Rashi. So the says when it sees the face of the mikt which would mean when it's brought into the of the mto says the according to whose opinion is there says that you have a basket of and you brought it partially into half is inside and half is outside whatever part of it is outside whatever part of it is outside. They are still like that from it is not or for whatever matter that pertains to the part of the basket that's inside that part is hectish for every matter and therefore he would be if he's a eats from it. Another this was actually discussed before in the said placing it down in front of them holds back the coen from eating from it that must be done but reading the it says in the that's not says according to whose opinion is this so the mfortion point out that we already had in the gum before it brought the tan from rises that hold like this but here The asks and brings another source. The source is from the Tana and this connection of to the G this connection of to the G before to the one before that we just learned. No, there isn't a connection. It's another it's another. Okay. So according to who is this? according to the says there are three that he taught in the name of three. So this is a where the doesn't quote fully it's quoted only one of the are brought here the other two are not mentioned. So one

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today the B the last line we're in the talk bringing the to the…
2. 3:08that that means what do you do with the masheni? You bring it to even if…
3. 6:15the it's not considered to be so you could you don't eat the here's the lion…
4. 9:22therefore he says all but I think the here says that is not the only exception…
5. 12:33that there's no today as as broad as a carbon and the place of the mdish…
6. 15:38then the brought before we're in the same it mentions we compare that to that just…
7. 18:43this a good answer because This is a good answer according to the opinion there in…
8. 21:54and the is so here you see that the right way to eat is when the…
9. 24:58want even when they're now there it also uses that term they can eat both and…
10. 28:05the you could redeem it answers no if that would be the only thing we learn…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.