Nedarim 5

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin the three lines from the top of the where it says so we're in middle of a here the is discussing the concept of Yim regarding a NE when a person says an incomplete sentence and the mishna says that nevertheless the takes effect so in the Mish when it said this the mishna explained the person says then the adds that it's on this says that it's adds that it's on this says that it's only if he says this together if he says and then he adds regarding eating from you only if it says it together then it's going to be that's what said but the brought twois where you see clearly that even if he just says without the conclusion of or even if he just says without it'll still be two we brought so therefore the gar switched this and the gar actually said that what this and the gar actually said that what sh was saying is when a person says the whole sentence M then what happens is you become AER to eat from your friend and that's it your friend is not AER from you you spelled out that it's regarding you eating from your friend but if you just say then what happens is this is a kind of a lotion that's not so clear so actually in this L what's going to happen is you're going to be also from your friend and your friend is also going to be also from you because included in this when you say the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01begin the three lines from the top of the where it says so we're in middle…
2. 2:35say the one that h n was made on him the one that the was made…
3. 5:11that if he said the clearly I am on you and you are then then they're…
4. 7:48says now according to how did he explain what is our speaking about that and all…
5. 10:51says it's is coming to be lenient what he's saying is if you said the full…
6. 13:22speak with him so some say that because it's not clear what he means he's actually…
7. 16:01this so from it seems if it's not then it's not says yes this is what…
8. 19:08word so therefore this proves that even with an incomplete sentence you still have to have…
9. 21:44the double that an incomplete sentence will make you a but it has to be clear…
10. 24:23have could even go according to the's opinion that say that by a g even without…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.