Sukkah 24

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we begin today in the gemara and gimmel amit bays a few lines from the bottom where the gemara brings a territs from abaya regarding a contradiction whether we are are we concerned about a person passing away or about an animal dying so let me just quickly review what we were learning before we're talking about using an animal for the wall of a sukkah and rab maya says we can't use it because according to our bias shot we're concerned that the animal will die concerned that the animal will die and you won't have the height of tenth for the sukkah so that's rob mayer yehuda disagrees says no we're not concerned the animal will die so you can use it for the wall of a sukkah a contradiction abbaya himself said that the opinions of ramayana yehuda are reversed when it comes to our case where a husband or cayenne left out of town and we're not sure if he's alive or not and the relevance is whether his wife could still eat truma or not could still eat truma or not so there's a mishna that says that she could still eat roma but then there's another place where it says that she can't eat rumor so the answer baeder said was that it's a much like us between and and our mayor is the one that's not concerned that the husband died and of yehuda is concerned that the husband died so he says mamish the exact opposite of what he said over here regarding ramayana viewed his opinion with the wall of the sukkot being made out of the body of an animal so the kamado now

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we begin today in the gemara and gimmel amit bays a few lines from the bottom…
2. 2:33is not concerned that the husband died and and the other one that it says that…
3. 5:34opinion so as rashi says the basis of robert's opinion is the concept of bereida which…
4. 8:08and it's not it says we have to reverse the answer of abaya here regarding the…
5. 11:10concept of breda why what's what's the issue why they don't hold of the concept of…
6. 13:43according to your opinion that you rely on this but nevertheless there's another problem won't you…
7. 16:53separation so using an animal as a gailo as a covering for a cavity or a…
8. 19:26not a tangible so therefore that's the issue it's ishmael in essence is not when what…
9. 22:30so what is the trader saying when it says safer that has to be written on…
10. 25:06know that you can't divorce your wife with money i see the answers miss chris the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.