Sanhedrin 79

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin today the towards the bottom of continuing the regarding that is from one that had an intention to kill an animal but he ended up killing a person the way Rashi explains this mishna is that we're talking about a case where there's an animal and right near the animal there's a person standing there and there someone that's aiming to kill an animal but now he gets a warning from aen that tell him that if you're going to aim to kill this animal there's a person that's standing right there and you might kill the person as well and the person accepts the warning the person says yes I know if I kill that person I'll be but I'm doing it anyways right so not it's not just St an animal he's accepting also that the way he's aiming it may end up hitting him and he that's one example now similar another example he's aiming to kill a but he killed a that was standing right near him and he got this warning he aimed to kill someone that's a n which is not considered to be a viable not a viable child not someone that's alive that and he killed a live healthy person so in all these cases poter he'll be poter for what he did so Rashi says based on the shot that I just said from Rashi why is he Potter he got the warning and he accepted the warning and he understood that the way he's aiming it it could kill this uh y this this person because it's still called it's a warning where there's a

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin today the towards the bottom of continuing the regarding that is from one that had…
2. 3:08loins and hitting him on his loins it's not able to kill this person but he…
3. 6:59cotton or it's a godle and he killed the cotton and you're going to be should…
4. 10:42in such a case according toim that's already called MAV because you're not saying I want…
5. 13:51another that this person would be because if it's all so the group of people we're…
6. 17:35identity of of somebody or something within a place not someone that was plish from an…
7. 21:21ACC what do you do how do you translate this if he did not in intend…
8. 24:31clarifying over here regarding this when you damage that it doesn't make a difference if it's…
9. 28:18know who's the murderer to be so so they're all going to be because you don't…
10. 32:11that they're all going to be PO is obvious how could you kill any just because…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.