Yoma 17

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we're starting the gemmata today and zayn and madalif the second line from the top and the gemada here comes back to the contradiction that it asked on the bays if you look back there you'll see there was a contradiction between the two mishnas of tamid and midis regarding the location of the lishka sattvim inside the basa market in one mission it said in the mission of tamid it said that the location of the lishkas its finest it says that the location of this lishkasatlayim was in maharava's dramas that was the question so the last plot of the gemara it basically said that the tana of musa and he holds that it was the tannen tom it holds that it was swainas madavas it's just a mahleikis of tutanayam of where the location of this lithius atlan just out of haga before we go fighter there's a secret from the rabbi where there's a secret from the rabbi where the rabbit talks about the mishnah mishnayis of midis where the mother goes through a whole long discussion here to prove that the stam mishnais of musa is was very very clear and therefore the rabbit says which discusses the middles of the basa mikhtash refers to the away of sadique and ablyzabinyakev also taught an iphone of clear everything was clear like the of clear everything was clear like the aveda vatsadik which is clear without any bumps in the road and that's why the tana of midis is here the gemara is going to come and give another answer to to this contradiction between tamid and midis again regarding the location of the lishkas at floyem and the gemara will explain that there's no argument and it just really it depends on the angle that you enter into the room based on the angle that the person's looking it'll be it'll seem to be in

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we're starting the gemmata today and zayn and madalif the second line from the top and…
2. 2:02looking it'll be it'll seem to be in different sides of the room so let's see…
3. 4:36that it was along the might of wall and it was closer to dottem than it…
4. 7:08in the mishna midis it says that it was dry mist sorry of yeah the very…
5. 9:18so then the answer that we're giving for the contradiction regarding the location of the panem…
6. 11:51at miz rochester i miss because you start off with swinous mud office then you go…
7. 14:26take a portion from the carbonis ahead of everyone else so we that elaborates more on…
8. 16:29mother is soon going to explain even though the lachem upon it was 12 breads but…
9. 19:01la mesa of the coin god it's not that heritage to give the cayenne a slice…
10. 21:37dividing the breads uh and we have to if you want to give the coin gotta…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.