Megillah 20

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we begin the gamata today towards the bottom of the test summit base about 10 lines from the bottom where it says this gemara is discussing the mission that said that cannot read the megillah and obviously we're talking about a haresh that can talk but he cannot hear usually that's a person that's a full bandass only if you're deaf mute you're usually potter from all mitzvahs but this person can speak but because we're talking about a mitzvah of reading the magilla and you have to be able to hear what you're reading you're reading so over here if you can't hear you're not you're not yet to the magilla you can't read the magilla that's what it said on our mishnah so we had a discussion in the mother before whose opinion is this is this going according to rabbi that says that even be the evid even be the heavy is not going to be yet at all if you can't hear or the mother says maybe it's going according to yehuda because even though the beauty says that ash will be yay but that's only be the evidence should not be reading the megillah so when it says maybe it's only talking about and it goes according to his opinion so that's that's what we learned until here right now the gemara is going to discuss his opinion itself because it's actually not so clear what his opinion is and the point that gemma is going to discuss is when rabbi says that that a person that says shema or a person that reads the megillah and he could not hear it that is yitzha did he mean to say yo it's only be the yeah that or does he mean to say yay even

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we begin the gamata today towards the bottom of the test summit base about 10 lines…
2. 2:32mitzvah like any other mitzvah and you have to make a bracha so the question is…
3. 5:40says even you don't have to say it loud and there's no question here we had…
4. 8:44those are the three opinions of our suggestion i mentioned before the reason we're comparing it…
5. 11:48and therefore that you can't accept what he says happened to him when he was a…
6. 14:49megillah and what does it say here yom during the day by young men by day…
7. 17:28he's compared to a balcherry the omission of a balchetti and azov is not exactly physically…
8. 20:31it is kosher because really allah starts that's that's when day begins not immediately from where…
9. 23:34they worked so if it's only day that they worked and it says that they worked…
10. 26:43theoretically though if you don't have very late right most of itself though it could be…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.