Sanhedrin 72

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

towards the bottom of the that we learned about in this the fact that his even though he's only a young he's just about 13 years old and he did what what did he do as the describes before he stole from his father and mother he doesn't listen to them and he was then he bought for cheap meat and wine and uh just this alone we say that he's how could be so the M says the reason is because he's punished now because of where this eventually will lead and we say y the says that he should die while he's still meritorious and he shouldn't die once he is already going to come to the place where he would be and then he would be completely will describe a little more for this and from this we learn out a general thing that a Russ when he dies it's for him and it's for the entire world when when the dies it's for himself because now he has less of opportunity to continue doing Aus so he suffers less as well and the world also suffers less if the r is eliminated sadik that leave the world it's negative for them because they can't continue doing mitz and it's bad for the world as well it can't benefit from their in the world yeah true is also afterwards correct wine and then drink and sleeping which wine brings for a person to be drowsy and to sleep so if it's that are drinking wine and sleeping it's good for them keeps them away from trouble and it's good for the world that they're out of trouble they're sleeping if they're sleeping it's bad for themselves and it's bad for the world as well to be scattered around they shouldn't when you have they not together

Jump to a moment

1. 0:05towards the bottom of the that we learned about in this the fact that his even…
2. 4:31because he will be involved in other things as well that will cause him to be…
3. 9:24of when you're a more stringent punishment than the lighter punishment doesn't apply so if you're…
4. 14:11have to kill him first right so therefore the Assumption over here is that this ghv…
5. 19:03here by the case where he's obligated to return it that you're obligated to return it…
6. 23:57is still fully intact if this you don't have to pay it back butash says the…
7. 28:46as well then so then you're allowed to kill him but that's only if it's 100%…
8. 33:33that you're not allowed that is when you're not allowed to kill him because it's a…
9. 38:20why do I need a special P by this he can kill him in any way…
10. 43:08according to it means literally that the child is not considered to be a at all…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.