Kesubos 33

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we begin the gemara today on daflam with basal with bay is the last line so this will continue our discussion which is a mahalakis between and ullah we had our mishna that says that in a case where there's both a malcus and that is when he had a relation with a sister or any other of that is so there's both knacks and malcus so ullah says the rule always is you pay you don't if you have have two punishments the rule is you pay and not punishments the rule is you pay and not malcus in a case where there is no payment because the girl is not a naira she's a begetta so then the class doesn't apply so then there's marcus ravier says the exact opposite whenever you have moment and malcus the rule always is malcus if there was no warning so then there's no malcus so then you pay and that's what our mission was speaking about that there was no warning does not accept all the source ullah brought before pasik he brought exercise which taught that whenever there's mommy and malcus you always have to pay so what what does that be going to do with that source why doesn't he accept xavier says so the answer is because him came if you're going to accept that so you're being mature you're nullifying

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we begin the gemara today on daflam with basal with bay is the last line so…
2. 3:35now over here the regular halakha of kashi zamam does not apply because how you're going…
3. 7:40kaseft that what i'm sorry we will be like this that you're paying the 50 coins…
4. 11:48and they get a chance to retract it so it's still all considered to be one…
5. 15:57goes back to something we spoke about before which is also regarding by a person harming…
6. 20:03have a muslim how do you know that this concept is true that if you're being…
7. 23:38when there's malchus and there's more mine you pay and there's no malcus but now what…
8. 27:41harsh muslim it's also considered a warning for something lighter what does the titan here say…
9. 31:45says that even when you get malchus like it said in the mishnah marcus but you…
10. 36:16just like when there's a sale obviously the transaction consists of this that is someone else…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.