Shabbos 8 - flipping an object in public domain, throwing on top of beam, throwing large object

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

where it says gufa. This is a statement that was brought before in the name of Rav Chisda on Amud Aleph. And the Gemara brings it now again and explains it in more detail. Gufa, this is the statement that we learned from Rav Chisda. Amar Rav Chisda, "Not kana b'reshus hayachid." A person sticks a pole into reshush hayachid. V'zarok v'noch algavav. And he threw from the reshush harabim and it it landed on top of this pole. Afilu g'voha me'ah amos, even if the height of this pole is 100 amos tall, chayav. Doesn't matter, he's still chayav for transferring the item from the reshush harabim to reshush hayachid when it lands on this pole. What's the reason? B'nei reshush hayachid oleh ad l'rakia. Because the reshush hayachid extends upward all the way to the rakia. There's no limit in the height of reshush hayachid. Unlike reshush harabim, which only extends up to 10 t'fachim. Leima, so the Gemara is actually going to focus on another detail over here in what Rav Chisda is saying. The pashtus of the chiddush of Rav Chisda is how tall the reshush hayachid goes. It goes even up to the rakia. But we're talking about a kana. A kana is a pole which is not four by four t'fachim wide. So, if the item lands on the top of this pole, pretty good aim. Pretty good aim. He throws it throws it from reshush harabim and it lands right on top of this pole in that little spot. But it's not four by four t'fachim wide and it has to be that minimum measurement to be chayav. So, leima, shall we say Rav Chisda, Rav Chisda that says over here that even if

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00where it says gufa. This is a statement that was brought before in the name of…
2. 4:15ha'yachid, the tree is in the reshusa yachid, but v'nafei nafei l'reshus ha'rabbim, and the branches…
3. 8:27that's 4 by 4 to walk him wide? So, Rashi says the measurement is 1.4 times…
4. 12:38there's something that's sticking out above 10 toachim. So if it's landed and part of it…
5. 16:47It's not comfortable for people to use to position their packages on it. Tisha, the exact…
6. 21:31not apply to vessels. It's a box, and there's no There's no takana of karmalis regarding…
7. 25:49he can't carry out from the to the oven. Rather the here is the less the…
8. 30:02storage in the reshuss harabbim. So, now Abaya is going to bring a support from a…
9. 34:17look, then I maybe would have thought just like he look at that is good to…
10. 38:35minani? He's allowed to take something from the oni that's standing in the reshus harabim? How…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.