Eiruvin 45

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] okay so we learned yesterday we're here on dalat on the base towards the bottom and the gemara brings an argument there between rabbi and of shimmy barrier regarding a case where a person had his original tom shabas when shabbos began but then he was allowed to go out of his home either because he was going to be a witness for killer shahidish and you're allowed to go out for that or to save someone's life so then in middle of the way he was told that he doesn't have to go any further he's not needed anymore needed anymore so now he has a neutron shabbos where he where he stopped so the question is if his neutron shabbos overlaps his old home do i say that because it overlaps he's allowed to enter back into his original home or i say no even if it overlaps he can't go back in he has this neutron that was established for him where he is now and that's the home of 2000 amazon you can go and not more that was the mahogany's says it overlaps he could enter in and said he can't so ignore he's going to ring a few so ignore he's going to ring a few questions of this but five lines from the bottom will you not agree that when you have two men that overlap each other that that's something that is could be accepted that now he can go into his old home and he brings the following example what would happen if a person is takes up his dwelling for shabbos we're in a in a cave

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00[Music] okay so we learned yesterday we're here on dalat on the base towards the bottom…
2. 4:03because there's two entrances so he can come out from either way and he's allowed to…
3. 8:12original tom so what do we see over here that trabaja says that as long as…
4. 12:18our question was because in the ratio it said that you could only go back if…
5. 16:30it's not a question he says a different shot there is a case where you have…
6. 20:39and they're taking things from their from their uh piles of grain so we learned this…
7. 24:50he is allowed to enter because he established his home he was he was travis within…
8. 28:55or you can choose to walk forearms to miter but once you choose one direction then…
9. 33:05akali which is hefke the commit the only reason they're arguing about a person that's asleep…
10. 37:23i'll bring you another diet what it says i'll bring you another case where you see…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.