Bava Basra 78

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin today a person sells a donkey he hasn't sold along with it its vessels the will spell out what kind of vessels we're talking about he sells the donkey he does sell the vessels along with it says sometimes when you sell the donkey the vessels are sold along with it and sometimes not it depends what's being sometimes not it depends what's being said here if the buyer says sell me this donkey why is he adding the word I skipped the line something sorry okay how is this if there was in front of him and the and there's the the vessels on this donkey and the buyer says me this donkey so why is he saying adding that cuz he wants to say saying adding that cuz he wants to say that the C The Vessel should be sold along with the donkey as well however if he says it as a question he asks the the the seller this is your donkey so then a then the are not sold because there's nothing extra that he saying here that indicates that he wants to include the as well he's just simply asking him is this your donkey so then it's only the donkey that's sold explain thisy this the way it is and there on it it's as well they're and there on it it's as well they're included as well all included right so says Mish speaks here about the of the donkey what are those so the argument in the is regarding sack that comes with the donkey or dis a a sack that's a s on the saddle saddle bag a saddle bag the as we'll see soon will say is a seat that's made for when women ride on the donkey so that's the is those are things that

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin today a person sells a donkey he hasn't sold along with it its vessels the…
2. 2:33only for riding but also for carrying merchandise on it and a woman to ride in…
3. 5:06answer now the answer is no that's not the this really I can tell you that…
4. 7:39you whether includes the Cale as well so then I could say this is going according…
5. 10:14ab came to argue and say regarding that case when it's on the donkey that it…
6. 13:17called anti it's merchandise that's on the boat okay so now if so we can prove…
7. 15:48sail is the m here that says that when you sell a donkey the C are…
8. 18:22included and with regarding all other cases as well so goes back to the first case…
9. 20:57this is the end of Simply theim there are speaking about that conquered the territory of…
10. 23:30so and then it says in the they consume what's this that they consume this is…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.