Bava Kama 97

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin to the towards the bottom of about 12 or 13 lines up from the bottom of the where it says so the here quotes from what it said in the okay so the T and the Mish said when a person steals either be or a and then its condition changed it got weaker older so what happens is because of the sh the Gin is the itself or the themselves and then they just have to pay back the value that it was at the time of the Gen argues ra says by a you can't be because a are compared to and by K you're not you never Co it you always give it back in its condition the way it is today to its owner that's the point of [Music] May leaves the majority opinion of the and like why would he do that so they said to answer this because had that brings the same as the mishna but it brings the opinions in the reverse that it's the that said that EV is compared to K so when he says is like he meant to say the way it's appears in the in the right so in other words he's really pasing like the will soon explain that's he's he's going he's ping like the like it says in the you're telling me that is taking the version of this argument the way it appears in the over the version the way we have it in a mishna a mishna is much more reliable always than a why is he taking the switches the names of the opinions in the M as well so the questions that why would switch the opinion in the mishna seems like that he's switching the opinions of the mishna because he saw that in the opinions are brought

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin to the towards the bottom of about 12 or 13 lines up from the bottom…
2. 4:11that's born still belongs to the first owner of the cow or it was after the…
3. 8:58says the regarding the case of where there's a doubt regarding the maid servant that gave…
4. 13:14should have to pay for all this time that you use this person's slave answers what…
5. 17:59because said a a slave even the value of the food that you feed him his…
6. 22:10him for living in his house again even though it's not actual ribus because it's a…
7. 26:53back the value of the money of this coin the way it was when you stole…
8. 31:07tra over here even though the physical coin is the same but nevertheless the change here…
9. 35:47from from history from times before but it sounds like though if would be not such…
10. 40:09back can take that money and use elsewhere you could take it to M and use…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.