Zevochim 7

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today 10 lines down from the top of the where it says we learned the following or the following. A person is bringing a carbon which is usually brought in a case where one of the four things that are in the of where one has to thank Hashem and you bring a special carbon taid. It's aim but it's additionally a taid. Now he brought this taida but what was the kavana that the k had lash. So there was ruven bringing a carbon tida and a shim bringing a carbon tida. And this kion is thinking that this is shim's carbon instead of ruins. Now what does this sound like? This sounds like what we learned before a kavana that's called shin that the kayan changed his kavana and he's thinking about the wrong owner when he's bringing the carbon. But that's actually not what our gam is talking about. We learned before Rashi mentioned it in the gam also that shinib is only in a case where the kan has a kavana in any of the aes that the of the dam which is the main kap of the carbon will be done for someone else. So he's doing it for an atonement for another individual. That's what's called shin. That's not what happened in this case over here. Here he's shackling the carbon and instead of thinking that this is the of he's thinking this is the of that's the case here now this is actually similar to a case that the is going to bring soon where where the kind is the carbonas and he has in mind it's

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today 10 lines down from the top of the where it says we learned…
2. 3:15that will only possle the carbon in a case where ruven is bringing the carbon for…
3. 6:58because I would think to say since I see that in one way there's a connection…
4. 10:14for someone else that's not any carbon at all. This carbon will be possible. Now it…
5. 14:10level of a kapare in this katas and therefore it will be a kavana that will…
6. 17:19exactly is their obligation to bring this carbon their only it's not even their carbonal and…
7. 21:04is the cha that a person does and then after that you bring the carbon as…
8. 24:17we see the source that by all of all the of the he can't have a…
9. 28:13regarding not having a for a different carbon then when it says the so here this…
10. 31:21in the previous it's adding here also the ander and therefore I I see already from…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.