Bava Basra 34

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin to the nine lines up from the bottom of the someone says to his friend my what are you doing here in this uh in this property like same as all the stories that brought until here so he ANS I bought this property from you and I'm here for three years I have aak I'm using this property already for three years I see he brought only one witness to testify that he's there for three years so what happens now so in such a case if you could only bring one witness that he's there three years so that's not a proof for a so the actual property itself since he doesn't have that he was there for three years he's going to have to return it to this one that was challenging his ownership and that individual that's challenging his ownership has aen that he was the previous owner he is the m so if you can't establish that you have a on this field you have to give it back to him field you have to give it back to him but now the question though is this is the second most learn this way the question here is what happens to all those three years that you were here and you ate the pis in this field for all this time you were using the fruits the produce of this property for all this time what happens to all of that there's an that said that you were eating here that you use this all for all these three years and what are you saying about that you're saying of course I ate it it's mine I bought it so in a way you're not really arguing with with what the is saying the is just saying that I saw you eating these fruits and you're

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00begin to the nine lines up from the bottom of the someone says to his friend…
2. 2:05that the case here could be compared to another story that's called is a a piece…
3. 4:37saying that you grabbed it from him and you're standing and screaming it never happened you're…
4. 7:10claimed that he did not grab it so then the would be that he has to…
5. 9:14question here what thear says that we have a fourth option that the gar does not…
6. 11:48not saying against the actual content of the words of that says that you grab it…
7. 14:20grabs this n they're testifying against him they're saying that he's a golin that you grabbed…
8. 16:23this so then it would be if there would be a case where a person is…
9. 18:59that this boat is mine is they can fight it out whoever grabs it it's his…
10. 21:34stronger then you prove it's yours but now he's asking B to release it again so…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.