Menachos 83

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today the gam 14 lines up from the bottom of the last word on the line. So we're in the middle of a sugi here. The Mishna brought regarding a carbon taid that if one has an obligation to bring a carbon an obligation to bring a carbon. We learn from the that it says that just like the carbon must be brought from something that is so too brought from something that is so too regarding a carbon it also has to be brought from since the word bakar it does not belong by a pes because pes cannot be brought from bakar. said from there we learn that it applies to a tida that it must be brought from and not from sheni. So the here brought according to that by pes itself we know that it must be brought from and not from because we compare pes to pes in pes there was no mi to bring to pes in pes there was no mi to bring from. So, so too regarding pes has to be brought from that was the limo according to but the brought in the rabbaka disagrees with this rabbaka held that you can't learn out from pes as the gumar explained before and now here the gumar begins and explains that rabaka according to rabaka's opinion from where does he know this that if a person has does he know this that if a person has an obl obligation to bring a carb in that has to be brought from something that is and not from something which is my okay according to what is his source that by the pes and similar by other carbonis the fact that it could only be brought from where does he know this

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today the gam 14 lines up from the bottom of the last word on…
2. 3:42other but the asks on this you don't have to learn from the there before besides…
3. 7:53carbon that's ple and it gets absorbed into something else. So we say that it has…
4. 11:59that so we learn all that we learn outlin just like if one has the of…
5. 16:08the word and here this word is the source for the we're looking for we learn…
6. 20:17can hear from here that this applies by other as well. Okay, this the two opinions…
7. 23:56so from this we learn out we learn out from there that there's another carbon that…
8. 27:58and in its age then I say it becomes but if it's already after its time…
9. 32:08What it says in the Mishna that the must be brought from the grain of the…
10. 36:17word before I go to the answers and that word that yeah it says but that's…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.