Sanhedrin 55

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

to right at the beginning of the this is actually a middle of the is quoting before but it starts one that has a relation with the which was mentioned here in the mishna and in the case of one that has a relation with a um yeah okay we'll see here different about this let's see so the continues here and says one that has a relation with whether in in the normal manner or the abnormal manner this is so here we're talking about a man that has a relation with a beh and or a woman that has a relation with normally or abnormally in both cases they're that's the okay so here the brings that spoke about this and it will ask from this on what they said by a woman that has a relation with an animal because quoted before in the end of so it uses the plural term regarding a woman so therefore we say that if a woman has a relation with an animal so then whether it's normal or abnormally the applies however according to what is saying here is a man that has a relation with a so over here because it doesn't say Mish by a man so the is only applies if it's in the normal manner as normal you can as you can call this okay it's it's it's only one one in the normal manner not in the abnormal manner that's what said asks on this on the contrary if you want to make a distinction between a man or a woman that have a relation with a the should be the opposite by a woman where this is more normal so because it's normal so if she has a relation with the animal in the normal way so then for that she will

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01to right at the beginning of the this is actually a middle of the is quoting…
2. 3:12man not it's very hard to understand this so I did not see a good but…
3. 7:03byid it says there the the term of as well that's the that it says by…
4. 10:46relations Is and then you in such a case so here it's no different you would…
5. 14:41a tree definitely you should have to kill the animal as well so now based on…
6. 18:28where a person had a relation with an animal there's a bigger embarrassment and the case…
7. 21:33say this is the animal that so and so was Stone through this animal so what…
8. 25:12Wells so there the says the girl that's three years old so there's different regarding regarding…
9. 28:54considered to be it's considered to be an a that animal caused her to do had…
10. 32:32but does not apply because he's still just a cotton and here the M clearly says…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.