Shabbos 145 squeezing juice of veggies lemons into food, witness of witness valid? Various questions

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] okay we started kuffman on the base today where it says um about six lines from the bottom of the almond so we'll return over here to the saw of srita um a person could squeeze a cluster of grapes into a pot of food so if you have food that's already there in the pot and you squeeze the grapes directly into the food that's not a problem and the reason is as we explained yesterday the only issue when it comes the issue that there is when it comes to shrita is when you're taking a liquid and removing it from the substance of food but if you're taking the liquid out of this grapes and the liquid itself doesn't have a status of liquid it's really food as well because it's not being taken out as a juice it's being taken out as a food to eat it so then it's like separating two pieces of food from each other that's not the malach of srita so here if it's going directly into food if you take not the juice for the purpose of eating in the food then there's no there's no problem that's if it goes and took data to but not if you're doing the shrite into a plate if you're doing it into a plate that has no food inside of it so then there is an issue of srita now the way rashi explains this kamada here is you look into the gemara itself it would seem that when you do this into the plate so then that's srita now the juice comes out into a plate where there's no food in it so that's

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00[Music] okay we started kuffman on the base today where it says um about six lines…
2. 4:16there's going to be an issue of separating the milk from the from the cow which…
3. 9:04massive ass from another case to may mace a person that's tommy mays soccer van oven…
4. 13:22really it's not it is a mashkah and here there's a different argument we're talking about…
5. 18:15considered to be a mashkah and therefore it's separating one food from another food which is…
6. 23:05potter avalosa it's still going to opinion on this matter and he says question whether you're…
7. 27:13november you only have manatee when you're squeezing all of the grapes which have naturally the…
8. 32:03if it was just a mishneh and i would say in the mishnah you have the…
9. 36:13town of girls this hand prepares gaza of gaza said i was once a nerd israel…
10. 41:19a i cry and the video the positive says that the eve from the oil the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.