Menachos 5

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today the gamif five lines down from the top of the binish the gum before brought a statement from regarding a carbon it's a carbon that's brought on the second day of pes to be m the new grain of the season so regarding this carbon said that if it was brought you brought it for the sake of another it's going to be completely possible and the reason is because the purpose of this mah is to be M the since if you bring a ch it's not m if it's not m then the whole carbon loses its whole existence and purpose and it's ple now the over here brought a that refuted's opinion says right before this clearly says that even if it was brought it's not going to be m but the carbon itself will still be so continues and brings what said about this said it is. However, the leftovers of the flower of this you cannot eat this. Why? Because you're going to have to bring another to be m to eat from this because since it was brought so the was not accomplished. So you can't eat from the flower of this which is from the from the of the season even though the actual itself is going to be but you can't eat from it and you're going to have to wait until you bring another. So the asks on this after the parenthesis if that's the case then

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today the gamif five lines down from the top of the binish the gum…
2. 4:18comes automatically without bringing >> yeah we'll see okay let's see yeah said well let's see…
3. 8:32no we don't wait for that say there we you can bring the now and then…
4. 13:10to the rule that said that because in the same day you're bringing the afterwards so…
5. 17:21time when it's so therefore when you brought this here you can't say that it's not…
6. 22:15pel that does not have any effect there you have to have three conditions has to…
7. 26:23be brought as a carbon so why do I need this bucket to teach this to…
8. 30:40with it. You're doing the kamita with it. And this is something which is for anybody…
9. 35:32so even if it's if you saying it's a year of and according to there's even…
10. 39:49what does that mean we're talking about a person the person is not so the clarifies…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.