Chullin 12

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We begin today the Gemara on daf yud beis, four lines down from the top of the amud. It starts the Gemara Amar Rav Nachman Amar Rav. You were observing someone shocheting the animal. If you saw the whole shchitah from the beginning until the end, then you're allowed to eat from this shchitah. But if you didn't see the entire shchitah, oser lacho mishchitahsei. You're not allowed to eat from the shchitah. shchitah. Okay, so here the Gemara will explain what exactly is this case that this halacha is being said. In fact, the Gemara dami, what are we talking about? Ee, the yada degomer, if you know for a fact that this shochet here is a person that knows all the halachas, he was fehered and you know he's a bakki in the halachas, this is what was called earlier in the mesechta here, a mumcheh. If so, lama lira? Why is it necessary to observe his shchitah? He can shochet without observing his shchitah. Ee, the yada deloy degomer, if you know for a fact that this is an individual for a fact that this is an individual that does not know the halachas, then pshita, then obviously you're going to have to observe his shchitah to know that what he's doing is going to be okay, that his shchitah will be okay. Here actually the Rishonim discuss what the Gemara is saying, pshita that you have to observe his shchitah. Earlier in the mesechta was mashma that a person that's not a mumcheh, you're not allowed to have him shochet even if you're observing his shchitah, he shouldn't be shocheting. Here the Gemara says that if you know that he doesn't know the halachas, then pshita that you have to observe his shchitah from the beginning till the end. So there's different

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We begin today the Gemara on daf yud beis, four lines down from the top of…
2. 2:33shouldn't we rely on the following thing? Derov metzuyan eitzu shchita mumchin hein. Most people that…
3. 5:33will also be done perfectly. If you could do one, he could do the other and…
4. 8:06But in another place in Shabbos, Rashi says that if you'll eat a quarter of the…
5. 11:10that most people that are going to be shochtim, we can rely on the fact that…
6. 13:44shita? So, I'm going to have to explain no, they're not arguing so in such extreme…
7. 16:47understood what Rebbe was saying is that and when it's in the bayis, I pasken like…
8. 19:21garbage that's still in the house. So, therefore, the Gemara reinterprets what Rebbe meant to say.…
9. 22:24l'chatchila. Amar Rava that zeh same matter. From this expression of yakal I understand that ain…
10. 24:59shita. Who is this of Nosseni? This is of Nossen. The tiny Is she is either…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.