Bava Metzia 45

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Oster Gemara Shiur’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

begin today the about 15 lines up from the bottom of the where it says I'm recording the share today from my Mon's Hospital in the SCH here I'm here with my son shom for him so this piece of G here is a continuation from what we learned in the beginning of the p and the basis of the point of the mishna is that when it comes to metalin any movable items in order that a kinion should take effect you have to do an act of ainon in the object that you're acquiring then there's payment money that you pay that's a separate thing that comes after but the actual Kenyon is only only takes effect when you do a Kyon in the so when there Z and there's gold coins and silver coins and people are two people are exchanging gold coins for silver coins so what we need to determine over here is which is the object of this sale and which is the payment so the gamar before brought two versions that rabi said in his Youth and in his older age whether the zah the gold is considered to be the object the commodity and the CF the silver coins is considered to be the money the payment so it's only when you do the act of the Kenyan by lifting up or taking the zahov that's when the Kenyon takes effect or the opposite it's the silver coins which is the object which is the commodity and

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01begin today the about 15 lines up from the bottom of the where it says I'm…
2. 4:49expensive this is the money so therefore over here when he has the silver coins which…
3. 9:38say that maybe only when it comes to the actual fruits to be on the gold…
4. 14:34opinion so what do we see from this now if so we could learn out from…
5. 19:26coins to buy in you buyy buy the groceries just some fruits and vegetables so you…
6. 24:54this is allowed is because B holds being on money a second time is not an…
7. 29:32say if a person has copper coins and he wants to exchange all of his copper…
8. 34:18going to prove that the last opinion fits into the of the Mish the best second…
9. 39:09p with gold you can acquire money at this point thear starts off and it understands…
10. 43:52whichever one you gave to the to the seller as as thein why should make any…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.