HALAKHA DAF | SANHEDRIN 34 | Lun19 | DafHayomi.fr

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rav Israel Abib’s own words— taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Hello everyone, today I'm going to try to talk about a subject that lies at the heart of all the laws, namely, how to decide a law. We all know that there's no possibility of going back over generations; we can't always refer to the previous generation. That is to say, the authorities of the say, the authorities of the Gemara cannot contradict the authorities who existed at the time of the Mishnah. Furthermore, the authorities will never be based on the Gemara. We all know that there's a kind of hierarchy that has been created over the course of all the generations, and after a certain time, we consider that a generation is already a new generation, and we no longer have the possibility of referring to those who came before us. Authors, in general, will not refer to the authorities of the past, and we won't refer to the authorities of the past. There were also the authorities of the past, and the authorities won't refer to those who came before us. Those who came before them, who will not be on the basis of the Mishnah, which created this hierarchy, and why there is no possibility of discussing the matter other than what existed in previous generations—the subject we will try to develop today in our writing—is that there is a difference between when there is a judge who has ruled correctly and then contradicts him, contradicts his ruling (PSAC). In that case, his ruling (PSAC) is considered null and void; it is not valid at all, it no longer exists, and it is automatically annulled. If, on the other hand, the ruling (PSAC) is on something that is

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03Hello everyone, today I'm going to try to talk about a subject that lies at the…
2. 1:43between when there is a judge who has ruled correctly and then contradicts him, contradicts his…
3. 3:43us understand that each generation cannot be lenient on the previous generation. How did this hierarchy…
4. 5:18later will no longer be able to be on this subject, and the same thing they…
5. 7:20and the way of deciding Laot and making judgments on the psukim from generation to generation…
6. 9:15only the truth that compels us to think this way because after the Mishnah was closed…
7. 11:22the period following, there are certain Rabbis, certain fikim who can be compared to the preceding…
8. 12:55of their city who also didn't know. So the Daanim of their city had a special…
9. 15:02in fact, there is here a gathering of all the... and this gathering has a force…
10. 16:39rather rare cases where the archonim, for example, are referred to the Rishonim, but even so,…

About Rav Israel Abib on Lehallel

591 approved videos from 2021 to 2026, 72 of them searchable by their own words. Open all of Rav Israel Abib’s shiurim →

Most played

Baba Metsia Daf 29 - 18 Adar 578326:58 · 152 views · Mar 27, 2024Baba Batra 4 | Daf Hayomi Shiur by Rav Israel Abib43:53 · 119 views · Jun 28, 2024MAKKOT 3 | Daf Hayomi Shiur by Rav Israel Abib34:46 · 111 views · Apr 10, 2025

More from Rav Israel Abib

📜 BEREISHIT 5787 | FROM ONE END OF THE UNIVERSE TO THE OTHER | Rav Israel Abib10:04 · 106 views · Oct 45786|! | HEAVEN MATCHES PEOPLE… | Rabbi Israel Abib8:52 · 47 views · Aug 19Résumé 5min - Daf Hayomi Houlin 1059:53 · 25 views · Aug 12📜 SHOFTIM 5786 |! | LIVE IN THE PRESENT! | Rav Israel Abib8:50 · 30 views · Aug 10Résumé 5min - Massekhet Houlin 5 | DafHayomi.fr3:55 · 43 views · May 3Résumé 5min - Menahot 110 | Daf Hayomi3:36 · 36 views · Apr 27

More on this topic, from other speakers

Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 108 by R' Eli StefanskyRabbi Eli Stefansky · 58:45 · 5.5K views · Aug 16Daf Yomi: Makkos 16 | Rabbi Shmuel SilberRabbi Shmuel Silber · 49:37 · 246 views · Apr 24, 2025Daf Yomi: Chullin 50 | Rabbi Shmuel SilberRabbi Shmuel Silber · 53:16 · 206 views · Jun 198 Min Daf - Temurah Daf 7 by R’ Eli StefanskyRabbi Eli Stefansky · 7:14 · 22 views · Jul 26, 2019