Daf Yomi: Makkos 16 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Hashem. Uh good. Today's daf is tes zayin 16 and we are picking up Hashem on tes vav amud beis and we left off with my we actually got a little bit further but let's let's just pick up with that. Good. But my so if you remember again we had an interesting so we have if you remember really what we call you so this take fundamental about about the nature of the nature of lav sheish b'ma'aseh or lav ani takum assei. Right? So remember again we saw lav ani takum assei you personally commit a lav a prohibition and then that prohibition has an accompanying assei which allows us to go ahead and essentially fix the lav. So if a person fails to perform the assei then the high in general sense in a general sense a person is not going to be malchus when they go ahead and when they go ahead and violate the assei. Sorry, when ahead and violate the assei. Sorry, when they violate the lav. And the reason for that is because I have the assei to be able to fix it. Now what happens if a person doesn't go ahead and perform the assei? Then I'm malchus. So the becomes the becomes at what point is a person going to be malchus then? What at what point do we call it non-performance of the assei? So this was a so we and we said bittul bittul lav bittul patur. Essentially if you do something which fundamentally precludes the performance of the assei.

Jump to a moment

1. 1:08Hashem. Uh good. Today's daf is tes zayin 16 and we are picking up Hashem on…
2. 5:41say that's not that's what's called in other words the way works is that has to…
3. 10:59day goes by and he doesn't eat it. He doesn't eat it. I will both say…
4. 15:35To teach me that I don't get Marcus love classy so again so we'll say so…
5. 20:43Shimon. Or hikah shneihem babasachas, or he hit both of them at once. At once. So,…
6. 25:20machlokes Rabbi Yochanan and Reish Lakish generally again about how lav hanitak l'asseh works. Rabbi Yochanan…
7. 30:28mirror saying anytime you find a low say that has an accompanying a say even if…
8. 35:06kidushin for for another man. Okay. So how does exactly that work? I'm really I'm really…
9. 40:08There is another case like this. Let's say again, I took the mashcone of a gear.…
10. 44:48essay? I don't know what I say again. I don't know what I say again. Now…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.