Lehallel
Getting it ready…

Torah · 2:54

Can parents really save a rebellious child? The answer changes everything.

18 views · Aug 17, 2026

Avi Fishoff — TWiSTED Parenting

A profound exploration into the laws of the rebellious son reveals a startling insight about redemption.

Read the notes on this shiur: outline, sources, and more from Avi Fishoff — TWiSTED Parenting →

Ask this shiur

Ask in your own words — the answer is the exact moment this shiur speaks to it.

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Avi Fishoff — TWiSTED Parenting’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

So the Halacha Shulchan Aruch says, it's been cited in the Gemara, we have a kid who does not listen. He's rebellious and defiant. What did he actually do? Garnish. He took his daddy's credit card. He went on Uber Eats. He ordered a steak. He got some wine. And for that, you kill him? So the Gemara says, he will end up in a few years from now joining a gang, selling drugs, and people are going to die. If somebody is running in the street with a gun, you don't wait for him to pull the trigger. You got to kill him now. There's a problem with that. The Gemara in Sanhedrin Daf Perek says, "She ratzu Av u'Im al Yimchalu Maichlin." Mommy, Daddy come and they say, "We Maichlin. I forgive you." So you forgive him. So the Shem Mishmuel says, "I don't understand." But you're not killing him for what he did to the parents, for ordering Uber Eats and getting some wine. Because we determined that he for sure will be a murderer. So then if Mommy and Daddy come and they say, "I forgive you."

Jump to a moment

  1. 0:00So the Halacha Shulchan Aruch says, it's been cited in the Gemara, we have a kid…
  2. 0:30There's a problem with that. The Gemara in Sanhedrin Daf Perek says, "She ratzu Av u'Im…
  3. 1:01How do you set him free? That's the kasha. He answers like this. A klal should…
  4. 1:32chain, you can get out of any situation that you're in. If he's connected to the…
  5. 2:02who is disconnected from Tati and Mommy, he's rebellious. You know what his problem is? Not…
  6. 2:33kill him. You have chills from this. It's possible that he can come back with teshuvah…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.

More from Avi Fishoff — TWiSTED Parenting

Get the week’s best, by email

One email a week — a handful of shiurim and music. No account needed.

Know a family who would use this? Give a Lehallel membership.