Q&A- Artscroll, Kol Isha & Mikva (Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

but i'm asking a question for the benefit of a talmud yeah okay if i know let's say for sure that i'm not going to be a ready i'm not going to be rubbing a shiva or off of a shul or something like that so what's the benefit of learning how to learn i could use art scroll why why should i learn how to learn if you're not going to be a ready you're not going to be teaching you know if you're rob in the show what's the benefit of learning how to learn why not just use art school um because the goal of learning is not just to assimilate information one of the goals of learning is to learn how to think i need to learn how to think not speak not just because you're teaching other people but because you base all your decisions on your thinking and if your thinking is warped or is primitive or it's clumsy then you're not going to make such good decisions so people ask i suppose it's a similar question although the form is different but this the point is the same why did ravina ravashi write the kimura why did they write the rambam you know why did they write the rambam you know just tell us what to do just give us a list of halachus the rambam invented shakhonoroks just codes of law there were no codes of law before the rumba and it was controversial he won i mean there are hundreds of codes of law today right but but it was controversial in its time and the answer is because the gemura is largely a record of conversations that people had and in their conversations you see what kind of arguments they used you see when

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00but i'm asking a question for the benefit of a talmud yeah okay if i know…
2. 2:36that so i think that's it's straightforward intellectual terms and the terms of running your own…
3. 5:39okay the question is how much work should you do when you're responsible for a family…
4. 8:13poverty leads a person to steal um doesn't even deny god the murderer says at the…
5. 11:18and he's working a 40-hour week and making a lot of money he said so why…
6. 14:20the nation there's a government to to the individual because if the if the answer is…
7. 16:53he comes down he sees everybody going over to the sink and washing their hands oh…
8. 19:58there are a lot of opinions in coalition it's not obvious that under the conditions that…
9. 22:32that's physical contact that's more than coalition so i you really need a sack from from…
10. 25:38when i lived in baltimore i first moved there the only mikvah available was the mikveh…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.