Q&A Bavli vs Yirushalmi, Tisch, and Minhagim (Rabbi Dr. Dovid Gottlieb)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

um what's exactly the difference between thomas bobby and your xiaomi and why is bobby top most like or in general um i think the the basic answer is history the talmud yoshami was edited about 100 years after the formulation of the mishnah was edited 250 years after that so the tablet is largely a compilation of discussions of the mishnah and it means that the babali includes much much more than hiroshami because it covers a much longer period of history including the period of history of the irish army but another two and a half centuries not only that not only that but there was constant contact between the babylonian scholars and the the israeli scholars there were several people who made trips back and forth and brought the latest if a patient from each side to the other side and um there's a gemura in manohars which when i came across it gave me a tremendous insight into this question the mother is talking about a certain the mother is talking about a certain law of citizens and they're disgusting and expressing various views and a visitor to the group offers a view with an argument and it's clearly superior to everyone else's contribution thank you very much it's clearly superior to everyone else's contribution and the people in the home group are a little bit embarrassed and the rash yeshiva says why are you embarrassed he's from israel meaning meaning so of course he knows better i mean you shouldn't expect him to know better now the e in that discussion from israel was ravina ravina is one of the two editors of the talmud pavlii which means one of the editors the babylonian talmud was himself an israeli scholar which means that the talmud bible has in it a very strong injection of the learning of the land of israel

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03um what's exactly the difference between thomas bobby and your xiaomi and why is bobby top…
2. 5:42here he says well the way you explained it i don't see any holes either i…
3. 11:46don't you dare eat our precious sacred animals no no you need to say that looks…
4. 17:23wine we make some mozi on bread it speaks for an hour 40 minutes is a…
5. 23:38so i i it's kind of like overwhelming to some people say i have to take…
6. 29:47musical uh like their own kind of their their outlook their their take on things the…
7. 35:24it's been a hit all over the world so this this type of literature that this…
8. 41:46will go to the world to come they won't suffer punishment or pain but it's a…
9. 47:29imagine someone's talking about eating and how it's an animal it's a it can be an…
10. 53:38of each of these items each of these subjects and trace it back to the source…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.