Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb - Verification of the Torah Part 2

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb’s own words— taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

newspaper um that is credible but then to look at other newspapers and see if they say the same thing what do you say for the argument that it was that the Torah is just one uh one medium uh for truth that perhaps there aren't any other sources telling us that this happened and therefore we can't use it as a credible Source okay this is very important um two things to be said here first of all your point can be Tak in first of all your point can be Tak in two different ways and both of them have to be answered first of all should we say without external collaboration I don't trust Just One Source well what are we going to do with the witnesses with Peter and Paul all I have is these two people no videotapes no mangled body no dented belt buckle no I have no other evidence I don't dismiss them on the grounds that I don't have other corroborating sources I don't do that there are cases when one source of information can be a credible source information can be a credible source based on its record of being credible so if the suggestion is without corroboration I never trust the source that's for sure not correct your parents your parents tell you what you did there's no external corroboration doesn't mean you should throw out everything they say if they prove to you that they're reliable reporters you should trust what they say simply not correct that I always need another corroborating uh Source but if you say why aren't there other collaborations weren't there other ancient Traditions didn't they have records why is that our story isn't

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00newspaper um that is credible but then to look at other newspapers and see if they…
2. 1:31records why is that our story isn't recorded someplace else that's a different kind of of…
3. 3:03down the fact that it's not there is perfectly all right indeed it's perfectly consistent with…
4. 4:34own prophets no so it wasn't as if they had Revelations that's not what the mid…
5. 6:04sacrifices to the Babylonian Gods because they have local control and Babylonian comes to Egypt will…
6. 7:37watch the Revelation I mean it's both situations it's a very large number of people cooperating…
7. 9:11does he have to tell me but then I can figure out an answer he says…
8. 10:42claimed that the sun Shook and the whole Sky shook I think it was off Malaga…
9. 12:14a place where they said there were lights most nights red and white lights on the…
10. 13:47they say we know that we've seen that God speaks to man and we heard his…

About Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb on Lehallel

104 approved videos from 2007 to 2026, 53 of them searchable by their own words. Open all of Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb’s shiurim →

Most played

Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb's questions for "evolutionists"15:48 · 211K views · Jun 24, 2016Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb on Richard Dawkins' Master Argument12:44 · 7.8K views · Apr 17, 2016Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb- Answering a Skeptic Part 1 ,morals.48:52 · 4.9K views · May 6, 2012

More from Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb

Introduction to Rosh Hashanah’s Machzor726 views · Sep 10The Times of Moshiach1.2K views · Sep 4Rewards in this World for Keeping the Torah386 views · Sep 3The World to Come837 views · Sep 2Q&A – Leaving Israel, Disagreement With a Rabbi (Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb)44:57 · 519 views · Aug 25The Mitzvah of Teshuvah – Responsibility for Our Actions40:32 · 216 views · Aug 25

More on this topic, from other speakers

מעמד סיום הלכות שבת בכולל "שיח יוסף"המרכז למורשת מרן - הרב עובדיה יוסף · Jan 22Rabbi Yussie Zakutinsky on Jewish Mysticism and the SoulRabbi Yussie Zakutinsky · 41:15 · 2.6K views · Aug 3Yaakov Wolff Answers Your Questions with Rav Ari KoretskyShtark Tank · 1:01:00 · 180 views · Aug 3Derech Hashem / The Way of God #57 | What Does The Satan REALLY Want?Rabbi Mendel Kessin · 1:35:50 · 14K views · Nov 28, 2016